AcademiaAesthetics
Image: Doré's English Bible (scan set on Wikimedia Commons) · Public domain

Moses Breaking the Tables of the Law

Gustave Doré, 1866

Moses Breaking the Tables of the Law is a wood engraving after Gustave Doré for his 1866 illustrated Bible (La Grande Bible de Tours). Against a lightning-split sky, Moses raises the stone tablet to smash it as the Israelites cower below (Exodus 32:19).

Date
1866
Medium
Wood engraving
Movement
Romanticism
Themes
Religion & Saints, Power & History, Literature & Poetry, War & Violence

What you are looking at

Moses towers over the picture against a storm-lit sky. He is seen from below, a massive bearded figure in heavy robes that whip out behind him in the wind, and he holds the stone tablet of the Law high above his head in both hands, at the top of his swing. His face is turned down and half in shadow, all brow and beard. In a moment the stone will come down.

Behind him the clouds blaze white around the tablet, and a jagged bolt of lightning cuts across the sky at left. The tablet itself is the classic round-topped double arch, its surface covered in lines of script that the engraver suggests rather than spells out.

At his feet the people of Israel react. At left a crowd of figures throw up their hands or stare; one man, face down, has collapsed across a stone block. In the right foreground a younger man has dropped to the ground and throws his arms over his head to shield himself, looking up in terror. Beside him an old bearded man sits hunched and turned away, as if he cannot bear to look. The block of dressed stone across the foreground may be an altar.

Something is missing. The golden calf, the cause of all this, does not appear in the plate. Doré keeps the camera on the lawgiver and the guilty.

The passage: Exodus 32

Moses has spent forty days on Mount Sinai receiving the Law. In his absence the Israelites, losing faith, ask Aaron to make them a god, and he casts a golden calf; they offer sacrifices before it and celebrate. Moses comes down the mountain carrying "the two tables of the testimony," which "were the work of God, and the writing was the writing of God, graven upon the tables" (Exodus 32:15–16, King James Version).

Then: "And it came to pass, as soon as he came nigh unto the camp, that he saw the calf, and the dancing: and Moses' anger waxed hot, and he cast the tables out of his hands, and brake them beneath the mount" (32:19). He burns the calf, grinds it to powder, and makes the people drink it.

How Doré staged it

Doré chose the instant of greatest tension, the stone raised and not yet thrown, which gives the plate its charge. The low viewpoint makes Moses gigantic and puts us among the crowd below, looking up at him as they do.

He also removed the narrative clutter. With no calf, no dancing and no Aaron, the image becomes almost an allegory of the Law confronting a guilty people. The lightning is borrowed from the thunder and lightning on Sinai earlier in Exodus (19:16), carried down the mountain with Moses as a sign of where his anger comes from.

Exodus speaks of two tables. Doré shows what reads as one raised slab, perhaps the pair held face to face, and keeps the familiar arched shape that Western art had long given the tablets. Nor does he give Moses the horns or rays of light that often mark him in older art, a tradition that grew from the description of his shining face when he later comes down from Sinai.

How it was made

The plate is a wood engraving. Doré drew on the block; the engraver signed "Hotelin" at lower right, and Doré's signature is at lower left. Look at the robe: it is built from long ridges of parallel line that swell and taper to model each fold, with the brightest edges left as bare uncut highlights. The sky behind is cross-hatched in short broken strokes, so it reads as boiling cloud, while the tablet is cut in a dense, even tone that makes it look solid and heavy against the glare.

Publication

The engraving belongs to Doré's illustrated Bible, published by Alfred Mame et Fils in Tours in 1866 and known as La Grande Bible de Tours; Cassell, Petter & Galpin issued it in English with the King James text. It is one of a run of Moses plates in Exodus, alongside scenes such as The Giving of the Law on Mount Sinai and Moses Comes Down from Mount Sinai. Earlier in the sequence come Jacob Wrestling with the Angel and The Confusion of Tongues; the whole cycle is in the Doré Bible.

Meaning

Moses breaking the tablets is a scene about broken covenant. The people have broken faith first, and the shattering of the stone makes that visible. Jewish tradition also remembers that the tablets were later remade, and that the broken pieces were kept, a reading that turns the scene from pure anger toward the possibility of renewal.

Doré's plate is all anger. His Moses belongs with the stern, overwhelming figures of the Old Testament plates, alongside the judgment scenes of The Deluge and Samson Destroying the Temple. The low-angle hero against a stormy sky is a formula he used across his work. More of it can be seen on the Gustave Doré page, and the movement behind it in Romanticism.

Questions & answers

What does Doré's Moses Breaking the Tables of the Law show?

Moses, seen from below against a stormy, lightning-split sky, lifts the stone tablet of the Law over his head in both hands, about to smash it. His robes whip in the wind. Below, the Israelites throw up their hands, collapse or shield their heads. The golden calf itself is not shown.

Which Bible verse does the plate illustrate?

Exodus 32:19. In the King James Version: "And it came to pass, as soon as he came nigh unto the camp, that he saw the calf, and the dancing: and Moses' anger waxed hot, and he cast the tables out of his hands, and brake them beneath the mount."

When was Moses Breaking the Tables of the Law made?

Doré designed it for his illustrated Bible, published by Mame in Tours in 1866 and known as La Grande Bible de Tours. The English edition, with the King James text, came from Cassell, Petter & Galpin in London. The plate is one of several Doré devoted to Moses in Exodus.

Who engraved Moses Breaking the Tables of the Law?

Doré drew the design on a boxwood block, and the engraver who cut it signed "Hotelin" at lower right; Doré's signature is at lower left. The engraver translated Doré's drawing into ridges of parallel line for the robes and broken cross-hatching for the boiling clouds.

Why did Moses break the tablets?

While Moses was on Mount Sinai receiving the Law, the Israelites made and worshipped a golden calf. When he came down and saw it, he threw down the tablets in anger, breaking them as the people had broken the covenant. The tablets were later remade (Exodus 34).

More by Gustave Doré

All works →

Also from 1866

Related works